Twenty-year-old Katie Brenneman, having always quietly fancied Jonathan Lundy, jumps at the opportunity when the widower asks her to help him care for his two young daughters, but just when it seems like her dreams of a future with Jonathan are about to come true, a message arrives that threatens to expose secrets from a time in her life when she strayed far from the Amish way of life.

Widower and single dad Nick Conover, CEO of a Michigan furniture company, comes under fire when his parent company orders him to fire half the work force, and his life becomes a nightmare when someone begins threatening him and his family, driving him to desperate lengths to protect his loved ones.

In the late 1950s, a minister in the small town of West Annett, Maine, struggles to regain his calling, his family, and his happiness after a devastating loss.