While Massie and Alicia concentrate on finding the key to the secret room at Octavian Country Day School, Kristen struggles with new teammates, Dylan continues to obsess over her weight, and Claire questions the sacrifices she has to make to remain a Hollywood starlet.

A bet about wardrobes between the wealthy Massie and middle-class Claire results in a testing of old friendships, a forging of new ones, and a change for the student body at Octavian Country Day School.

Massie, Alicia, Dylan, Kristen, and Claire--five teenage girls with different reasons for wanting to attend the New Year's Yves party in Orlando--meet and form the Pretty Committee.

While on a seventh-grade school trip, Claire attempts to mend her relationship with Cam while Massie seeks to maintain her high social standing and receive her first kiss.

Five teenage girls with the power to see what boys are thinking about them must find dates for Skye Hamilton's "famous couples" costume party if they want to hang onto their popularity.