Mr. Gilbert and Mr. Sullivan, friends who write operas together, have a falling out when Mr. Sullivan refuses to compose music for yet another silly story, prompting Mr. Gilbert to try something completely new.

Talented songwriter Shawn Gallagher claims he is content with his life as it is, but his music tells a different tale. No one, including lifelong friend Brenna O'Toole, knows why he doesn't put his musical gift to profitable use.